From Front-Page Murder to 90-Second Cliff-Hanger
How a still-pending New York homicide case became the plot of ReelShort’s new vertical drama The Adjuster.
How a still-pending New York homicide case became the plot of ReelShort’s new vertical drama The Adjuster.
The real-world crime
On the morning of December 4, 2024, UnitedHealth Group executive Brian Thompson was shot outside a Midtown Manhattan hotel. Federal prosecutors later charged Luigi Nicholas Mangione, a 26-year-old former data engineer from Maryland who previously worked at TrueCar, describing the attack as “premeditated and targeted.” When agents arrested him five days later, they recovered a handwritten manifesto blaming America’s insurance industry for his family’s medical-claim disasters. Prosecutors have since asked a federal judge to seek the death penalty; the trial is set for later this year.
Public opinion split almost immediately. Some saw Mangione as a disturbed gunman; others, angered by years of denied claims and surprise billing, dubbed him a “real-life Batman.”
Enter The Adjuster
Before the indictment even reached its final form, short-form streamer ReelShort rolled out a vertical series called The Adjuster. Ads began hitting TikTok and YouTube on June 19, 2025, accompanied by a disclaimer that “any resemblance to real persons is coincidental.” Viewers didn’t buy it. The show’s hero, Matteo Leone, loses his little sister after a health-insurance cancellation, then guns down the CEO of the fictional “DB Health” … all details that echo the Mangione complaint. Even the lead actor’s styling: dark stubble, swept-back hair, disarming grin, mirrors the arrest-photo that splashed across cable news.
Why the series feels so familiar
The Adjuster lifts more than just the basic premise:
- In the real case, Mangione allegedly mailed letters from jail defending his act; the show’s teaser ends with Matteo dictating a manifesto to his supporters.
- Court filings note Mangione was photographed joking with a barista hours before the shooting; ReelShort’s trailer recreates an identical latte-counter smile.
- Prosecutors say a rejection letter from UnitedHealthcare was found among Mangione’s papers; episode one opens on Matteo holding a denial notice dated the day his sister died.
The casting isn’t accidental either. Behind-the-scenes photos show the actor’s everyday headshot bears little resemblance to Mangione; extensive makeup and wig work bridge the gap, a detail even U.S. viewers have praised in comment threads.
The micro-drama marketing math
ReelShort bought fewer than 700 ad variants for this test, low by its usual standards, suggesting a cautious probe. Each 30-second spot copies the studio’s normal funnel: open with a headline-style news clip, pile on insurance denial flashbacks and humiliation beats, then freeze-cut just as Matteo raises the gun. The swipe-to-install conversion is pure voyeurism: audiences who followed the real case want to know whether fiction gives the vigilante a different fate.
Ethics versus eyeballs
True-crime adaptations usually wait for a verdict, or at least a plea deal, before dramatizing events. Vertical drama moves faster. With a production cycle measured in days and a global user base conditioned to pay US $0.30 to unpause a story, “too soon” becomes a business-risk calculation, not a creative one.
ReelShort’s gamble is that the hunger for hot-off-the-press narratives will outweigh blowback from a still-grieving family and an untried defendant.
What happens next?
Mangione’s federal trial could begin as early as the fall. If prosecutors win a death-penalty verdict, The Adjuster writers may pivot to a darker season-two ending; if he’s convicted but spared, Matteo Leone might escape or negotiate a tell-all deal inside the show’s universe. Either way, the experiment signals a new, unnervingly short feedback loop between headline and handheld drama: one where real lives, legal outcomes, and thirty-cent paywalls collide in less time than it takes a jury to be seated.
Got thoughts on where the line should be drawn? Drop them in the comments pls. ;)
To know more about this series:
Real Reel™ Newsletter:
News, Analysis & Reviews for Vertical Storytelling.
